Skip to content
AppDivino

Scores and ratings

What wine scores mean: the 100-point and 5-star scales

A wine score is one taster's or one crowd's verdict squeezed into a number. On the 100-point scale, 90 and up usually means a well-made, recommended wine; on the 5-star community scale, about 4.0 and up is a good sign. Neither number tells you whether you will like the bottle.

Download DiVino on the App StoreGet DiVino on Google Play

By · Published

Three glasses of red wine lined up on a blank tasting sheet with a pencil

The chart: score bands at a glance

Bands differ a little between critics, and community stars are averages of many tastes, so read these as typical meanings, not rules.

100-point score5-star communityUsually means in the glassUsually means on the price tag
98 to 1004.6 and upStandout wine with depth and length; often needs timeOften expensive and scarce; allocation bottles
95 to 974.4 to 4.5Outstanding; layered and preciseUsually premium, with a collector premium for famous names
90 to 944.0 to 4.3Very good to excellent; the sweet spot for many drinkersWide range, from fair deals to name-driven pricing
85 to 893.7 to 3.9Good, clean, easy; made to be enjoyed nowOften everyday money and where many bargains sit
80 to 843.3 to 3.6Sound but plain; nothing wrong, little to rememberCheap, or priced above its quality by a brand
Below 80Below 3.3Flawed or dull; most critics rarely publish theseRarely worth buying at any price

How to read the table

The two scales are not the same measuring stick. The 100-point scale starts at 50 in theory but in practice lives between about 80 and 100, so a 100-point scale is really a 20-point scale. A critic tastes a wine, often young and in a flight, and assigns points. Stars come from many drinkers who tasted it at home, with dinner, in a good mood or a bad one.

That is why critic scores tend to cluster high and community stars cluster around 3.5 to 4.2. A 4.1 from thousands of drinkers is not weaker than a 91; it is a different kind of evidence.

Price follows scores loosely. Above about 95 you are often paying for scarcity and reputation as much as flavor. In the 85 to 89 band, you are mostly paying for the liquid.

Why a 90 is not a promise you will like it

A score measures quality as the taster defined it: balance, concentration, finish, typicality. It does not measure whether you want that style. A 92 oaky, high-alcohol red can be a poor match if you like light, crisp wines, and a 3.6 Muscadet can be exactly what you want with oysters.

  • Critics reward power and concentration in a tasting flight; at dinner, a quieter wine may win.
  • A young wine may be scored for its future, not for how it drinks tonight.
  • Different critics use their own bands, and the same wine can differ by a few points.
  • Stars from a handful of ratings swing wildly; stars from thousands settle.

We would trust a score most when it agrees with your own past favorites, not when it is simply high.

The main exceptions

Old wine is the big one. A bottle past its peak can lose points and stars even if it was great once, so check the vintage and drinking window as well as the number. Sweet, fortified and sparkling wines are scored by the same scale but compared within their own class.

Cheap bottles with very few ratings can show a flattering average, and famous labels often get stars for the name. Where a bottle has both critic points and community stars and they disagree, that gap is worth noticing; it usually means a style split between experts and everyday drinkers.

DiVino shows ratings with community and critic references plus a drinking window (Hold, Ready, At peak, Past peak) next to each scanned bottle, so you can see both at once. Results depend on a clear label, and the vintage can be misread on similar labels, so check the year printed on the bottle.

Using scores when you shop

Use scores to filter, not to decide. Set a floor (many people use 88 points or 3.8 stars), then choose by style, grape and food. Compare price at the same score: if two 90-point wines sit twenty dollars apart, the extra money is usually brand and region.

If you want a quick check of how much is wine worth against its score, DiVino gives an estimated value, which is guidance, not a formal appraisal. Apps that look up wine prices can show what merchants ask, and that helps you see whether a high score is already baked into the shelf price.

A good app for rating wine should show you where the number comes from, how many people rated it and whether a critic is involved. Community rating apps are strongest on popular bottles and weaker on obscure ones with a thin pool of votes.

A Tuesday evening at the shelf

It is an hour before guests arrive. You are standing at the shelf with two reds: a 91-point bottle at a high price and an 87-point bottle at half that. You are serving roast chicken, not a steak.

We would take the 87. Chicken wants freshness and moderate tannin, and a big 91 can flatten it. Scan both labels, look at the drinking window, and confirm the vintage. If the pricier bottle says Hold, it is probably too young tonight.

On an iPhone, a wine score app such as DiVino reads the label and shows the ratings and window on one screen. If you use a phone with Google Play, a wine ratings app works the same way, and DiVino is available there too.

Frequently asked questions

What are wine points?

Wine points are a score, usually out of 100, that a critic or publication gives a wine after tasting it. In practice most wines that get published land between 80 and 100, and each critic or magazine uses its own tasting method.

What is the number one selling wine in America?

By volume, Barefoot and Josh Cellars are often named among the best-selling brands in the US, and California Cabernet Sauvignon and Chardonnay are among the top-selling styles. Rankings vary by year and by whether they count dollars or cases.

Which is higher, Premier or Grand Cru?

Grand Cru is higher. In Burgundy and Alsace, Grand Cru marks the top-tier vineyards, while Premier Cru sits one step below it. In Bordeaux the terms are used differently, and Premier Cru (First Growth) is the top of the 1855 Médoc classification.

What is considered the best wine ever?

There is no agreed answer, because taste is personal and scores come from individual critics. Bottles that often appear in such discussions include great old Bordeaux, Burgundy from Domaine de la Romanée-Conti, and vintage Port, usually tied to a particular year.

What are the top 5 wines in the world?

No official top 5 exists, since each list reflects one critic's or publication's taste. Lists often feature wines such as Château Lafite Rothschild, Romanée-Conti, Screaming Eagle, Penfolds Grange and Château d'Yquem.

Do wine scores change as a wine ages?

A published score is a snapshot of the wine when it was tasted, usually young. As a bottle ages, it can improve, hold steady or decline, so the original number may no longer describe what is in the glass.